Controversy over existence of seized “incriminating material” for re


Share post:

the taxtalk

 10 total views

Controversy over existence of seized “incriminating material” for re (assessment) under section 153A/153C of the Income Tax Act laid to rest by the Hon’ble Supreme Court!


Lead case: Abhisar Buildwell P. Ltd. Case (CA No. 6580 of 2021) (SC) & Others.

Ratio: Assessment under Section 153A of the Act is linked with the search and requisition actions. Therefore, only in a case where the undisclosed income is found on the basis of incriminating material arising out of Search/requisition; the Assessing Officer would assume the jurisdiction to assess or reassess total income.

Take Away:

Type I cases: Abated/Incomplete Assessments: Irrespective of Incriminating material found or not (de hors); Total Income can be assessed for that Year. It is not clear whether 153A(2) is to be resorted to.

Type II cases: Unabated/Completed Assessments: Only if Incriminating material seized; Total Income can be re-assessed

Type III cases: Unabated/Completed Assessments: If No Incriminating material seized; Total Income can not be re-assessed u/section 153A/153C. Assessments quashed, though notices are valid.

Type IV cases: Unabated/completed Assessments: Can be re-opened u/section 147/148 of the Act – Revenue’s Powers for section 148/147 are saved.

Type IV cases and the saving of right of Revenue to issue section 148 notices/reassess under section 147 pose certain interesting scenarios!! Will it go the Ashish Agarwal way?


The copy of the order is as under:


Abhisar Buildwell – Kabul Chawla


Source link


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Related articles

Uttarakhand police chief asks pilgrims to stagger visit to Char Dham temples to reduce rush

The rush of pilgrims at the Char Dham temples in Uttarakhand is many times higher...

World Environment Day | How Tamil Nadu’s tiger reserves tackle the summer

A quintessential summer day in Tamil Nadu’s five major tiger reserves sees the dry rustle...

Beautification projects add splendour to Tangmarg and Gulmarg, J-K’s popular tourist destinations

Tangmarg and Gulmarg, two picturesque health resorts in north Kashmir's Baramullah District have undergone a...

Tamil Nadu’s Kodaikanal witnessing tourist boom due to annual summer festival

ANI | | Posted by Akanksha Agnihotri, Kodaikanal The queen of mountains, Kodaikanal in Tamil Nadu...