Friday, December 1, 2023

Creating liberating content

Lachung in Sikkim allows...

PTI | | Posted by Zarafshan Shiraz,...

Snowfall in Sonamarg, night...

PTI | | Posted by Zarafshan Shiraz,...

Yearend Travel: 10 best...

December 31 marks the last day on the...

New adventure zones in...

Tourists enjoying rides in kayaks and circular boat at the...
HomeNewsUpdatesConfiscated goods cannot...

Confiscated goods cannot be claimed as a trading loss incidental

the taxtalk

 223 total views

Confiscated goods cannot be claimed as a trading loss incidental to business: SC




The Commissioner of Income Tax Jaipur Versus Prakash Chand Lunia (D) Thr.Lrs. & Anr.

(Civil Appeal Nos. 7689-90 of 2023)


  1. The Director of Revenue Intelligence set out a search at the business premises of the Respondent/assessee. The recovery yielded silver slabs/silver ingots. The assessee was in the business of making jewellery.
  1. The Collector of Customs vide order dated 18.12.1990 ordered confiscation of goods and imposed penalty. It was done on the premise that the goods were smuggled by the assessee.
  1. A claim was made by the assessee that the loss on account of confiscation would be allowable as trading loss being incidental to the business, and hence, deductible. This argument was duly rejected by the AO as he did not own the silver. The AO made the addition U/S 69A.
  1. The plea of ownership was given up by the Respondent/assessee before the High Court, and therefore, the decision of the assessing officer in bringing the loss suffered under Section 69A of the Income Tax Act, 1961.

Hon SC held as below:

  1. The word ‘any expenditure’ mentioned in Section 37 of the Income Tax Act (deals with allowability of expenses) takes in its sweep loss occasioned in the course of business, being incidental to it.
  1. As a consequence, any loss incurred by way of an expenditure by an assessee for any purpose which is an offence or which is prohibited by law is not deductible in terms of Explanation 1 to Section 37 of the Act.
  1. A penalty or a confiscation is a proceeding in rem, and therefore, a loss in pursuance to the same is not available for deduction regardless of the nature of business, as a penalty or confiscation cannot be said to be incidental to any business.
  1. So the loss on account of confiscation of undisclosed silver cannot be allowed as a deduction.


The copy of the order is as under:




Source link

Get notified whenever we post something new!


Create a website from scratch

Just drag and drop elements in a page to get started with Newspaper Theme.

Continue reading

Lachung in Sikkim allows tourists from Friday after October flash flood

PTI | | Posted by Zarafshan Shiraz, Gangtok The popular north Sikkim tourist destination, Lachung, which was affected by flash floods in early October, has been made accessible...

Snowfall in Sonamarg, night temperature rises at several places in Jammu and Kashmir

PTI | | Posted by Zarafshan Shiraz, Srinagar Jammu and Kashmir’s Sonamarg tourist resort recorded light snowfall for the second day on Friday while the Meteorological Department forecast...

Yearend Travel: 10 best places to celebrate New Year’s Eve

December 31 marks the last day on the Gregorian calendar and it is one of the oldest holidays in the Western cultures. The first known record of New Year’s celebrations began about 2000 B.C....

Enjoy exclusive access to all of our content

Get an online subscription and you can unlock any article you come across.