No Deduction on Secondary & Sr. Secondary Education Cess Due to Tax Part


Share post:

Arpit Kulshrestha

Kolkata ITAT's Order for M/s Sarat Chatterjee

In an appeal about the secondary and higher secondary cess, the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Kolkata bench ruled that their education cess is part of tax and therefore no deduction will be provided.

The statement was held by the Kolkata ITAT when it received an appeal from an assessee. The assessee is challenging the order issued by the Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Kolkata on 25th January 2022 for the assessment year 2017-18.

As a result of the assessee’s appeal, which is the verification of the addition of Rs. 84,76,769/- by DRP, made by the AO/TPO, because of TP adjustment regarding the international transactions, without understanding the situation that TP provisions are not relevant as the assessee’s income was taxable following the Tonnage Tax Scheme, the brief facts of the matter were that the applicant had filed his or her income tax return on November 30, 2017.

In this, the applicant has revealed a total income of Rs. 17,07,17,340/-. The amount was considered for scrutiny under CASS and statutory notices were rightly issued and served on the assessee.

Examining TP criteria and the huge number of international transactions of Rs. 8.80 crores and specified domestic transactions (SDT) totaling Rs. 33.08 crores were two factors in choosing the case for scrutiny.

Read Also: GST Impact on Education Sector in India

Therefore, the reference was sent to the AO/TPO. And the TPO issued the order under Section 92CA (3), proposing the upper adjustment of Rs. 84,76,769/- on account of the transfer pricing adjustment.

As a result, this amount was added to the assessee’s income in the assessment framed under Section 143(3) read with Section 144C (13) of the Act dated January 25, 2022, among other additions.

The DRP disapproved the appeal in the appellate proceedings. It was done so with the help of recording its observations, and it is being discontented by the matter, that the applicant has chosen the instant appeal before the Kolkata ITAT.

The ITAT Panel of Sonjoy Sarma, the Judicial Member, and Rajesh Kumar, the Accountant Member, after hearing the opposing arguments made by Arati Agarwal and Rosy Banjerjee, the A.Rs, on behalf of the assessee, and by G. Hukugha Sema, the CIT, on behalf of the Revenue, held: “We have heard the ld. authorised representatives for both parties perused the orders of the lower authorities and the material available on record, and have also considered the judicial pronouncements that have been relied upon by them in the context of the issue in hand and also explanation 3 as inserted by Finance Act,2022 to section 40(ii) of the Act”.

Similar: Tax Benefits on Interest Paid & Full Time Education U/S 80C

Following the conclusion of the matter, it has been decided that tax includes any surcharge or cess, referred by whatever name, is deemed to have always included them.

A deduction is not accessible to the assessee due to the education cess and Secondary and Higher Secondary education cess being included in the tax due to the above-discussed. As a result, the assessee’s arguments are disapproved.

Case Title M/s Sarat Chatterjee & Co. VSP
Pvt. Ltd. Vs. ACIT, CC-1(1)
Citation I.T.A. No. 101/Kol/2022
Date 29.03.2023
Appellant Arati Agarwal, A.R
Rosy Banjerjee, A.R
Respondent Shri G.Hukugha Sema, CIT
Kolkata ITAT Read Order

Source link


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Related articles

Air France flight to Paris turns back to Osaka in Japan after malfunction

Reuters | | Posted by Zarafshan Shiraz, Tokyo An Air France KLM SA passenger plane flying...

Senior travel made easy: Tips for older adults to plan your summer getaway

Summer travel is a fantastic opportunity for older adults to explore new cultures, witness new...

Kashmir draws crowds as tourists seek refuge from rising temperatures

While most parts of the country are reeling under heat wave conditions, tourists are enjoying...

Egypt unearths mummification workshops, tombs in ancient burial ground of Saqqara to revive tourism industry

Egypt unearthed human and animal mummification workshops as well as two tombs in the ancient...