Wednesday, March 19, 2025

Creating liberating content

NASA astronaut Sunita Williams’ sister-in-law Falguni Pandya said she was

NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court on Tuesday decided to conduct

Build confidence with positive language The words parents use shape

Related News

NASA astronaut Sunita Williams’ sister-in-law Falguni Pandya said she was shown a photo of the Maha Kumbh from the International Space Station (ISS). In an exclusive interview with NDTV, she

NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court on Tuesday decided to conduct an in-depth inquiry into allegations of Arunachal govt’s contract largesse to firms owned by chief minister Pema Khandu’s relatives and

Build confidence with positive language The words parents use shape a child’s confidence and mindset. Certain phrases can unintentionally harm self-esteem or emotional growth. Avoid these common mistakes to foster

US President Donald Trump stands in the presidential box as he tours the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts in Washington, Monday (AP photo) US President Donald Trump

Google parent Alphabet agreed to acquire cloud security firm Wiz for $32 billion in cash, reaching a deal less than a year after initial negotiations fell apart because the cloud-computing

TOI correspondent from Washington: The smackdown was swift, but the blowback was brutal. The Trump White House on Monday reaped a whirlwind in history after sowing the wind with a

Trending News

Google parent Alphabet agreed to acquire cloud security firm Wiz for $32 billion in cash, reaching a deal less than a year after initial negotiations fell apart because the cloud-computing

Ashok Hinduja (File photo) To List Insurance Arms In 2 Years, Plans RebrandingMUMBAI : IndusInd International Holdings (IIHL) has completed the Rs 9,650-crore acquisition of Anil Ambani-promoted Reliance Capital under

Cipla has announced an exclusive licensing agreement with Taiwan-based Formosa Pharmaceuticals to market clobetasol propionate ophthalmic suspension 0.05% (APP13007) across 11 countries, including India. It is used to treat post-op

NEW DELHI: Hudco will become a zero NPA company with no bad loans in its books in the next 18 months, following resolution of projects worth around Rs 1,200 crore

India’s Largest Pvt Debt-Raise In Domestic Currency To See Participation Of 15 InvestorsMUMBAI: Five private credit funds, including Davidson Kempner Capital Management, Cerberus Capital Management and Ares Management Corp, will

Top stocks to buy (AI image) Stock market recommendations: According to Mehul Kothari, DVP – Technical Research, Anand Rathi Shares and Stock Brokers, BHEL, Astrazeneca Pharma and Maruti Suzuki India

Constituent Assembly settled CAG debate: Supreme Court | India News

Word Count: 719 | Estimated Reading Time: 4 minutes


Constituent Assembly settled CAG debate: Supreme Court

Prolific PIL litigant ‘Centre for Public Interest Litigation‘, through advocate Prashant Bhushan, told SC that though CAG was considered independent and impartial in the past, it had lost its stature because of the drop in number of audits it conducted of Centre and states governed by the party in office at Centre.
Justice Kant, however, did not seem to fully agree with the contention about erosion of the federal auditor’s autonomy. “We seem to have a great misconception about independence,” he said.
Bhushan said even for selection and appointment of SC judges, CVC and CEC, there were mechanisms provided to ensure their independence, yet SC thought it fit to lay down guidelines providing for a high-level panel, including leader of opposition and CJI, for their selection to ensure that these sensitive posts are manned by persons of impeccable integrity and enjoy independence while discharging their duties.
When Bhushan said architect of the Constitution, Dr B R Ambedkar, had envisaged greater independence for CAG than SC, the bench pointed out that the Constituent Assembly had debated the viewpoint but majority did not agree with it. “The issues and questions you raise about selection and appointment of CAG were squarely answered during the Constituent Assembly debates,” Justice Kant said.
The bench said there was already a PIL by one Anupam Kulshreshtha pending in SC on the same issue raised by Bhushan, who said though notice was issued a year ago, it was not listed for hearing again. Though the Constitution leaves it to the executive to appoint judges of SC and HCs in consultation with the CJI, SC in two judgments in the 1990s wrested the judge selection process to itself.
In the Vineet Narain judgment, SC had given statutory status to Central Vigilance Commission and set up a CVC selection committee comprising the PM, home minister and leader of opposition. CVC, home secretary and secretary (personnel) were mandated to select and recommend the person for CBI director post, which would have a minimum tenure of two years. A similar mechanism was laid down for appointment of ED director.
In 2023, SC had detected a vacuum in the law for appointment of CEC and ruled that CEC and ECs would be selected by a panel comprising PM, CJI and LoP. However, it also said it was for Parliament to decide the constitution of the collegium.





Source link

Most Popular Articles

Sign In

Welcome ! Log into Your Account